Quantcast

Pilot reliance on automation under scrutiny after fatal crash near Truckee

United Airlines CEO Reassures Passengers About Newark Airport Safety
American Testing Tech to Help Passengers Make Connecting Flights
British Airways to use AI in efforts to improve operations
American Airlines Tests New Tech to Help Passengers With Tight Connections During Summer Rush
Flight Diverted After Pregnant Woman on Board Goes into Labor and Delivers Her Baby: Report
United Airlines CEO Scott Kirby says "this is the most optimistic I've been in my entire career about finally getting the FAA fixed"
U.S. Transportation Secretary Sean P. Duffy Unveils Plan to Build Brand New, State-of-the-Art Air Traffic Control System
Passenger rushing for next flight can't believe what woman next to her does
Why fuel price crash won’t make flying cheaper
Kristi Noem says travelers without Real ID will still be able to fly after deadline
Frontier Airlines Announces New Routes Launching This Summer, Connecting Baltimore With Chicago O’Hare and Trenton, N.J. With Myrtle Beach, S.C.
Airlines in North America prioritize investments in cyber, AI
The evolution of the airline uniform — a cross check
Global Airlines & HiFly Operate 1st Passenger Airbus A380 Flight Between Barcelona And Berlin
American Airlines unveils ritzy new plane suites launching this summer
Airline Stocks To Keep An Eye On - April 28th
Gatwick Airport Faces Potential Strikes
50 New Routes Starting In May 2025
Report: JetBlue, United Mulling Partnership
New First-Class Suites, Futuristic Aircraft and the Top Air Travel News From April 2025
Southwest Airlines Announces Reimagined Fare Products, New Benefits for Rapid Rewards Credit Cardmembers and Tier Member Customers
New Alaska Airlines trading cards take flight this World Pilots’ Day - Alaska Airlines News
United CEO calls Trump's tariffs a 'chess game'
Virtual Training Becomes a Reality
Korean Air Restarts Longest 747 Passenger Flight in the World
Flight tickets from Srinagar remain exorbitantly high despite aviation ministry request
RTX Q1 Earnings & Sales Beat Estimates, Increase Year Over Year
Delta faces federal investigation as it scraps hundreds of flights for fifth straight day
Coalition pledges to remove EV tax break two days after Dutton ruled out scrapping it – as it happened
Adani’s airport unit seeks $750 million loan from global banks
Pilot reliance on automation under scrutiny after fatal crash near Truckee
Policy
Webp 898vmm0ovyiogs3i4ise06qknsub
Aviation International News | Aviation International News

In all my years of flying, whether as an instructor/evaluator or simply a member of the crew, I’ve never seen a pilot win a fistfight with the autoflight. As I was nearly done writing this article in early May, the NTSB issued its preliminary report on the fatal accident involving a Daher TBM 700, N960LP, near Truckee, California, on March 30, 2024.

In his report on the release, Gordon Gilbert wrote for AIN that “the preliminary accident report shows a series of autopilot engagements and disengagements” just prior to the accident.

Here’s the set-up: The airport was closed; the weather was IMC with ceiling and visibility requiring an instrument approach. The PIC was reported by the NTSB to have had 250 hours flying the aircraft. The preliminary report gives few facts beyond these initial findings, and we may never know why this series of apparent actions in the cockpit were taken.

Get the Newsletter
Sign-up to receive weekly round up of news from Sky Industry News
By submitting, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service. By providing your phone number you are opting in and consenting to receive recurring SMS/MMS messages, including automated texts, to that number from our short code. Msg & data rates may apply. Reply HELP for help, STOP to end. SMS opt-in will not be sold, rented, or shared.

Initial indications suggest that the pilot made several attempts to connect the autoflight while maneuvering the aircraft close to the ground in an area of high terrain at night in poor weather conditions. Drawing irrefutable conclusions from this information will be a challenge for the NTSB, but its final report will be one that many pilots will be anxiously awaiting. It had the effect of immediately reinforcing for me how important this topic is to contemporary aviation safety.

Inevitably, whether new to flying or a seasoned veteran with thousands of hours, every contemporary pilot will confront new technologies designed to increase safety margins and contribute to both efficiency and productivity. We all generally agree that those are good things—and wouldn’t have it any other way.

But unless we work for an organization that has resources to deal with these advances systematically through training and evaluation programs supported by a rigorous standardization team, many crewmembers are mostly on their own when it comes to smoothly blending traditional airmanship with contemporary automation. Whether adapting to enhanced vision systems like EFVS or SVS augmented with a head-up display (HUD), or the latest mandated communications-navigation-surveillance (CNS) systems and protocols, flight crews need extensive knowledge and proficiency which is not going to diminish in coming years.

Yet few training programs—even industry-leading ones—recognize the need for developing a balanced approach that blends proficiency with advanced flight guidance systems alongside traditional stick-and-rudder skills.

If you stay committed to a flying career long enough, eventually you will encounter conditions requiring manual control over automated systems. Yet real-world practice opportunities can seem scarce when aircraft and crew are engaged in revenue operations.

If you’re reading this thinking “Yeah, this isn’t a problem,” it may be because you haven’t yet experienced practical conflicts between manual control and onboard automated systems designed for flight path management. Aviation safety sources are plentiful; NASA’s ASRS system offers numerous reports detailing airborne crews grappling with autoflight systems in real time—a less than ideal scenario.

A recent search within NASA's ASRS database using criteria “Excursion from assigned altitude” plus “Human Factors/Human-Machine Interface” generated 648 results. These incidents highlight ongoing challenges where manual intervention could have been safer—a persistent issue our industry should address by refining relationships between hardware (aircraft integrated systems) and wetware (pilots).

This concern is shared by many pilots and has caught attention from researchers and regulators alike. ICAO is concluding its study on declining hand-flying skills—a significant research effort expected later this year—highlighted by Aviation Week & Space Technology journalists who noted increasing automation dependency over decades: from 22% during 1990-2010 up to 49% post-2010 among studied accidents/incidents involving flight-path issues.

The study states: “Technical advances in flight deck systems are not being supported with sufficient training or best-practices guidance,” leading many pilots towards excessive reliance on automation while lacking fundamental hand-flying skills.

Our research supports these findings; Convergent Performance emphasized mandatory hand-flying opportunities within SOPs as routine practice back in our book Automation Airmanship (McGraw-Hill Education). For instance: mandating manual departures instead of autopilot engagement at low altitudes fosters balance between autoflight proficiency versus manual control skills—though optimal policies depend on various factors including local conditions/experience levels/safety considerations necessitating continuous follow-up/fine-tuning post-implementation.

Veteran pilots’ experiences show preemptive decisions/briefings prioritizing manual control often precede potential conflicts over automated system use during flights.

Chris Lutat is managing partner at Convergent Performance/B777 captain/co-author "Automation Airmanship: Nine Principles Operating Glass Cockpit Aircraft."

Opinions expressed herein belong solely author/not necessarily endorsed by AIN Media Group.

Organizations Included in this History
More News

Planning a vacation on a private jet involves more than just booking flights and accommodations.

May 30, 2025

Air India has announced an extension of its suspension of flights to and from Tel Aviv until June 19, 2025.

May 29, 2025

Ethiopian Airlines has announced a double bonus miles promotion for flights between Lagos and any of its destinations.

May 29, 2025

Copa Airlines announced it has resumed flights between Panama City and Caracas as of May 27, offering daily service with plans to increase to two daily flights starting June 23, 2025.

May 29, 2025

Hainan Airlines has announced a new direct international route between Jeddah and Haikou, marking its first connection between Saudi Arabia and China.

May 29, 2025

Alaska Airlines announced it is launching Chef’s (tray) Table, a new First Class dining program featuring top West Coast chefs, beginning June 5 on select flights, according to a post on X. Alaska Airlines is introducing Chef’s (tray) Table, a...

May 29, 2025