Arizona hotel enforces vaccination policy in 2024

However, questions arise about whether this approach aligns with current scientific understanding. In early 2021, vaccines were largely effective at preventing transmission. Today, their efficacy has diminished; they no longer reliably prevent infection or transmission despite offering protection against severe illness.

The hotel's stance appears more sentimental than scientifically driven: "in loving memory of..” Nevertheless, it is meaningful to the owners and reflects their personal experience during the pandemic.

Critics argue that while vaccination remains important, it may not align with current science to require it for all guests given waning vaccine effectiveness and other preventive measures available today. Additionally, allowing exceptions for 'healthy' individuals raises further questions about what criteria determine healthiness—such as body mass index or absence of chronic illnesses—and whether these criteria effectively mitigate asymptomatic spread.

Ultimately, the Simpson Hotel's policy serves as a reminder of past practices during an unprecedented time in history when public health measures were rapidly evolving based on emerging data.

---