Quantcast

Debate over overhead bin use resurfaces after United Airlines incident

Southwest's layoffs dent its worker-first culture
Abu Dhabi's long-haul carrier Etihad Airways sees record $476 million profit in 2024
Jet2 warns of profits squeeze from rising costs and late bookings
Southwest bends further to activist shareholder Elliott's demands
Downgraded on a flight? Take these simple but important steps to get your money back
Hong Kong Airlines launches daily Sydney flights
Airline to launch new bunk beds in economy on long-haul flights next year
How Airline Employees Are Coping After Deadly Washington Crash
Major airline reverses in-flight menu change amid outcry
British Airways frequent flyer scheme changes: everything you need to know
Airline introduces world-first hand luggage ban on popular travel gadget
Air Canada Delays Boeing 767 Reentry
Flight Centre tips ‘price war’ as first direct Melbourne to LA Delta flights go on sale
FAA reverses course on meeting prohibition, blaming rogue employee
British Airways tweaks frequent flyer scheme after backlash
Delta flight from New York to Florida diverted to North Carolina due to ‘odor in the cabin’
EASA Certifies Safran’s First Electric Motor
US court blocks Biden administration's airline fee disclosure rule
JetBlue Issues Dim Outlook But Execs Remain Confident in Turnaround Plan
Delta to Resume Tel Aviv Flights April 1
Boeing CEO Ortberg outlines 2025 priorities after heavy losses
Storm Eowyn: Thousands of trains, flights and ferries cancelled as 100mph wind batters UK
Indian carrier long haul: IndiGo returns to profitability, plans long haul flights
These Frequent Fliers Are Done With Loyalty Programs
JetBlue accepting Venmo as payment method for flights purchased through mobile app
United Airlines stock rallies on results, as growing demand wasn’t just about premium seats
Delta Adds Another Alaska Route
Southwest to Reduce Pilot Head Count at Several Bases
Dublin Airport savings boost for holidaymakers – but passengers need to be quick
American Halts CRJ-200 Operations
Debate over overhead bin use resurfaces after United Airlines incident
Research
Webp uefmsw7k0lt5f20uxuve40u9xjr0
Airbus A380 | Airbus

A recent incident on a United flight from Denver to Houston has reignited the debate over proper use of overhead bin space. The altercation began when a passenger removed another traveler’s backpack from the overhead compartment to make room for their rollaboard suitcase.

The owner of the backpack reportedly "yelled at him to put it back and they got in an argument." The passenger with the rollaboard insisted that the backpack should be stored under the seat. Other passengers supported this stance, arguing that personal items should not occupy overhead bin space.

However, it was later revealed that the individual with the backpack had already placed a briefcase under his seat, making it necessary for his larger carry-on item to go in the overhead bin. Consequently, "roller guy was speechless and walked away with his suitcase to the back," likely having to gate-check his bag due to lack of available space.

Get the Newsletter
Sign-up to receive weekly round up of news from Sky Industry News
By submitting, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service. By providing your phone number you are opting in and consenting to receive recurring SMS/MMS messages, including automated texts, to that number from our short code. Msg & data rates may apply. Reply HELP for help, STOP to end. SMS opt-in will not be sold, rented, or shared.

This situation highlights a common issue on crowded flights where late boarders often face limited overhead storage options. Airlines charge for checked bags and planes are typically full, leading to quickly filled bins even when larger ones are installed. Southwest Airlines experiences fewer such issues due to its policy of including two free checked bags with each ticket.

Despite basic expectations around using overhead bins, moving other people's belongings is generally frowned upon. There could be legitimate reasons—such as medical needs—that require passengers to store items both above and below their seats.

Airlines like Delta, United, and American have attempted to address this by labeling bins according to cabin class, theoretically reserving space for late-boarding first-class passengers. However, enforcement of these labels remains inconsistent.

Ultimately, overhead bin space operates on a first-come, first-served basis. While flight attendants often instruct passengers to place personal items under their seats, enforcement is minimal. Passengers taking matters into their own hands may find themselves embroiled in disputes.

Organizations Included in this History
More News

Southwest Airlines, the largest carrier in the U.S. by passengers, operates approximately 4,000 daily flights across its network.

Apr 23, 2025

The story of Kalitta Air and its founder, Conrad "Connie" Kalitta, is rooted in a deep passion for drag racing that eventually led to the establishment of an international cargo airline.

Apr 23, 2025

The New York to Los Angeles flight route is one of the busiest in the United States.

Apr 23, 2025

The Airbus A220 is making strides in Europe, particularly with three airlines operating some of the longest routes on this regional jet.

Apr 23, 2025

Air India, the leading airline connecting India and the United Kingdom, faces increasing competition from British Airways, Virgin Atlantic, and India's low-cost carrier IndiGo.

Apr 23, 2025

Delta Air Lines' maintenance arm, Delta TechOps, has secured a new contract with UPS Airlines for service on its Pratt & Whitney PW2000 engines.

Apr 23, 2025