Quantcast

Starbucks baristas file brief opposing reinstatement of Biden-Appointed NLRB member

Starbucks baristas file brief opposing reinstatement of Biden-Appointed NLRB member
Webp cc1jt466ot7cmxbydq5pkg6hoj4s
Milton L. Chappell | Staff Attorney (1976-Present) | NRTWLD&EF, Inc

The National Right to Work Foundation has filed an amicus brief at the District of Columbia Circuit Court of Appeals on behalf of two upstate New York Starbucks baristas in a case that could impact the constitutionality of the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB).

The case, Wilcox v. Trump, addresses whether President Trump properly exercised his executive authority when he removed Biden-appointed former chair of the NLRB, Gwynne Wilcox. Trump Administration lawyers argue, as do baristas Ariana Cortes and Logan Karam in their own pending lawsuit at the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals, that the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) violates the Constitution because it restricts the president from removing board members.

Cortes and Karam are now joining the Administration’s legal team in requesting that the D.C. Circuit Court stay a lower court’s ruling reinstating Wilcox. Their brief emphasizes that they and others could be directly affected if Wilcox participates in an NLRB decision without being properly accountable to the President.

Get the Newsletter
Sign-up to receive weekly round up of news from Sky Industry News
By submitting, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service. By providing your phone number you are opting in and consenting to receive recurring SMS/MMS messages, including automated texts, to that number from our short code. Msg & data rates may apply. Reply HELP for help, STOP to end. SMS opt-in will not be sold, rented, or shared.

Cortes and Karam work at separate Starbucks locations in Buffalo, NY. In 2023, they each submitted petitions on behalf of their coworkers with sufficient support to prompt NLRB votes to “decertify,” or remove, the Starbucks Workers United (SBWU) union from their stores. However, NLRB officials indefinitely delayed these union decertification elections due to unproven charges against Starbucks Corporation by SBWU union officials. This led Cortes and Karam to file their own federal lawsuit challenging the agency’s structure as unconstitutional.

The issue regarding NLRB’s constitutionality gained traction following President Trump’s firing of Biden-appointed NLRB Board Member Gwynne Wilcox, which she contested as a violation of NLRA’s board member removal protections. Trump Administration lawyers countered with arguments similar to those in Cortes and Karam’s lawsuit, asserting that NLRB members’ removal protections allow them to exercise substantial executive authority while being immune to presidential removal for their term durations—something forbidden by U.S. Supreme Court decisions like Seila Law v. CFPB and Collins v. Yellen.

Cortes and Karam’s brief highlights how the Board’s powers to enforce federal labor law, lack of technical expertise, and partisan nature place it outside Supreme Court concepts where removal protections might be appropriate. It also argues that reinstating Wilcox would cause chaos because she would participate in deciding cases before her continued presence on Board is still subject to litigation.

“Cortes and Karam have a vital interest in this case's outcome...,” says the amicus brief.

“Ms. Cortes' & Mr. Karam’s amicus brief points out what many workers who have litigated before NLRB learned—the hard way—that it's a hyper-partisan agency...” commented National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation President Mark Mix. “While this issue will likely end up before Supreme Court ultimately... ”

More News

Flying Food Group (FFG) has announced its commitment to environmental causes through annual donations, marking World Wildlife Day and Earth Day this year with a contribution to One Tree Planted.

Mar 14, 2025

Flying Food Group (FFG) expressed its appreciation for its long-standing partnership with Japan Airlines (JAL) during an appreciation dinner in Los Angeles on February 25.

Mar 14, 2025

Heidi Alexander, the UK Transport Secretary, announced that the UK government is "minded to approve" Gatwick Airport's £2.2 billion expansion plan, which would allow for 100,000 additional flights per year.

Mar 14, 2025

Delta Air Lines Scrapping Austin-Harlingen Route After Commencing Flights Only 5 Months Ago Mar 11 2025 While much consideration and planning goes into starting new airline routes, there are times when they are suspended earlier than anticipated.

Mar 14, 2025

The Airbus A350 is renowned as one of the world's most efficient widebody aircraft, contributing to the decline of the A380 Superjumbo project due to its operational savings.

Mar 14, 2025

Minneapolis-St. Paul International Airport (MSP), also known as Wold-Chamberlain Field, is a major joint civil-military public international airport serving the Twin Cities region of Minneapolis and Saint Paul in Minnesota.

Mar 14, 2025